About Us


About Beneigh Insurance
Real Protection From Your Local Insurance Professionals
We are an independent agency deeply committed to our communities, helping you confidently prepare for life’s unexpected moments.

Our Philosophy
The Beneigh Difference
We know how daunting the insurance landscape can be. We repeatedly saw friends and family struggling to find the coverage they needed, which is why we purposefully abandon the "one-size-fits-all" approach. When you work with us, you receive our undivided attention.
Our Story
Built on Real-World Experience
Beneigh Insurance Group was built on the belief that insurance should be personal, reliable, and deeply rooted in the community.
Our founder, Andrew Beneigh, began his career in the field as a claims adjuster back in 2000. Experiencing the industry firsthand from the claims side provided invaluable insight into how policies actually work in the real world—and more importantly, what families and businesses truly need when disaster strikes. Driven by a desire to help people better prepare for the future, Andrew opened the doors to Beneigh Insurance Group in Zelienople in 2006. As our client base grew and our community ties deepened, we proudly expanded by opening our second office in Ellwood City.

Deeply Rooted in Our Communities
We do more than just work here; we live here. We care about the personal and financial security of the people and local businesses we pass on the street every day.
Zelienople: From taking in the sights at Horse Trading Days to watching a show at the historic Strand Theater and lining up on Main Street for the Fourth of July Parade, Zelienople is our home. We are dedicated to insuring the neighbors who grow and change alongside us.
Ellwood City: We love the sights and tastes of the annual Ellwood City Festival and watching the revitalization of Main Street happen right before our eyes. We value the everyday joy of bumping into clients and friends while out running errands.
Our Mission
Our mission is simple: to get to know your unique needs, wants, and long-term goals. We aren't afraid to think "out of the box" and challenge conventional wisdom to design a protection strategy tailored exclusively to you. The world can be an unpredictable place, but our ultimate goal is to build a long-term, trusting relationship that keeps you, your assets, and the people who matter most entirely safe.
Testimonials
What Our Customers Say?




