227 S. Division Street Zelienople, PA, 16063 info@beneighgroup.com
Your Neighborhood Insurance Agent |

Claims & Carriers

Our Trusted Insurance Carriers

At Beneigh Insurance Group, we are proudly an independent insurance agency. This is a crucial distinction. Unlike "captive" agents who can only sell policies from a single company, our loyalty is completely to you. We work for you, not the insurance companies.

Because we are independent, we have the freedom to partner with a wide variety of the nation’s most respected and financially stable insurance carriers. This allows us to actively compare coverages, shop for the most competitive rates, and build a truly customized insurance portfolio that fits your specific needs.

If you are an existing client who needs to make a payment or report an emergency outside of our normal office hours, you can access your carrier directly below:

Image

Erie Insurance Group

Founded in Pennsylvania in 1925, Erie Insurance is consistently recognized as one of the most reliable and customer-focused carriers in the nation. Operating with the foundational purpose of providing "as near perfect protection, as near perfect service as is humanly possible," Erie specializes in highly customizable auto, home, business, and life insurance products. They are renowned for their exceptional claims handling and their commitment to long-term policyholder relationships.

Image

Progressive Insurance

Progressive is a household name and one of the largest auto insurers in the United States. Known for pioneering modern insurance technology—including the introduction of drive-in claims locations and highly accurate telematics programs (Snapshot)—Progressive offers innovative, flexible coverage. Beyond auto, they provide robust options for motorcycles, RVs, commercial vehicles, and bundled home policies.

Image

American Collectors Insurance

Standard auto policies are designed for commuting, not for protecting a piece of automotive history. American Collectors Insurance is the premier provider for antique, classic, and custom collector vehicles. They understand the passion and investment behind the hobby, offering specialized "Agreed Value" policies, flexible mileage plans, and coverage for rare spare parts to ensure your masterpiece is fully protected.

Image

Lititz Mutual

Deeply rooted in Pennsylvania history, Lititz Mutual has been protecting properties since 1888. They are a mutual company, meaning they operate for the benefit of their policyholders rather than corporate shareholders. Built on a foundation of sound financial management and conservative underwriting, Lititz specializes in reliable, community-focused property and casualty insurance, providing absolute peace of mind for local homeowners and businesses.

Image

Agency Insurance Company (AIC)

Agency Insurance Company (AIC) has built a strong reputation as a regional provider dedicated to delivering fast, efficient, and reliable service. They focus on straightforward auto, motorcycle, and commercial vehicle coverage. AIC is highly regarded for its streamlined claims processes and user-friendly digital tools, making it easy for drivers to manage their policies on the go.

Have a Question

First Name *
Email *
Last Name *
Phone *
Insurance Type (Optional)
Question
Contact Us

Image

Office Address

Find Us On Social Media!